DESIGN FEATURES OF PROTECTIVE ANTI-DRONE SHIELDS
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.31650/2707-3068-2025-29-5-14Keywords:
transformer charging station, unmanned aerial vehicles, kamikaze drone, passive engineering protection, rotective screen, Shahed defenseAbstract
The paper examines the structural and engineering aspects of designing steel protective screens to counter unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) at energy infrastructure facilities. The relevance of the topic is due to the targeted UAV attacks on transformer substations, which have prompted the implementation of passive protection in the form of steel anti-drone screens. The study includes an analysis of recent research and publications on UAV threats to power grids and existing protection methods. It explores structural solutions for protective screens and presents the results of their practical implementation in Ukraine. The paper summarizes design requirements, including material selection, ensuring appropriate screen height and distance, modularity, and maintainability of the structure.
References
[1] Kyiv Post. Critical Infrastructure Objects of Ukraine: Everything You Need to Know. URL: https://www.kyivpost.com/uk/post/28283 (application date 20.04.2025)
[2] Law of Ukraine "On Critical Infrastructure" (2023), No. 1882-IX: as of 01.01.2024, based on No. 1909-IX. (Section III, Articles 8, 9, 10, 11). URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/1882-20#Text (application date 20.04.2025)
[3] Resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine, October 9, 2020, No. 1109 “Some Issues of Critical Infrastructure Objects,” with amendments. URL: https://ips.ligazakon.net/document/KP201109?an=1 (application date 20.04.2025)
[4] Council Directive 2008/114/EC of December 8, 2008 on the identification and designation of European critical infrastructures and the assessment of the need to improve their protection. URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/984_002-08#Text (application date 20.04.2025)
[5] Kotsiuruba V. I., Bilyk A. S., Veretnov A. O., Haidarly H. S., Borta R. M., Tertyshnyi B. I. Methodology for calculations and substantiation of requirements for the engineering protection of critical infrastructure objects from loitering munition-type UAVs. Strength of Materials and Theory of Structures. 2022. Issue 109. P. 164–183.
[6] Forbes Ukraine. Ukrenergo received €86 million from the EIB for anti-drone protection of substations. URL: https://forbes.ua/news/ukrenergo-otrimalo-86-mln-vid-eib-na-antidronoviy-zakhist-pidstantsiy-23122024-25819 (News about funding of protection projects for substations, includes quotes from Ukrenergo leadership) (application date 20.04.2025)
[7] Ukrenergo became the first in the world to implement comprehensive anti-drone protection at high-voltage substations // UNN, 04.05.2024. (Statement by V. Kudrytskyi on results of substation protection)URL: https://unn.ua/news/ukrenerho-pershym-u-sviti-vprovadyv-kompleksnyi-antydronovyi-zakhyst-na-vysokovoltnykh-pidstantsiiakh-kudrytskyi (application date 20.04.2025)
[8] Naumann S. The Threat to the Electric Grid of Drones Must Be Analyzed and Action Taken Now. Protect Our Power Blog, Jan 2022. URL: https://protectourpower.org/blog/the-threat-to-the-electric-grid-of-drones-must-be-analyzed-and-action-taken-now/ (application date 20.04.2025)
[9] Kootala A., Mousa A., Pong P.W.T. Drones are Endangering Energy Critical Infrastructure, and How We Can Deal with This. Energies, 2023, 16(14), 5521. URL: https://www.mdpi.com/1996-1073/16/14/5521 (application date 20.04.2025)
[10] VP 3-00(116)120. Methodological Recommendations to general military units on combating Iranian Shahed-136 (Geran-2) and Russian Lancet-2 strike UAVs (based on the experience of the Russo-Ukrainian war of 2022–2023). March 2023. URL: https://shron1.chtyvo.org.ua/Zbroini_syly_Ukrainy/Metodychni_rekomendatsii_zahalnoviiskovym_pidrozdilam_schodo_borotby_z_udarnymy_BpLA_iranskoho_vyrob.pdf (application date 20.04.2025)
[11] DBN V.2.6-198:2014. Steel structures. Design standard. With change No. 1. Valid from 2015-01-01. Kyiv: Ministry of Regional Construction of Ukraine, 2014. 220 p.
[12] DBN V.2.6-98:2009. Structures of buildings and facilities. Concrete and reinforced concrete structures. Basic provisions. With change No. 1. Valid from 2011-06-01. Kyiv: Ministry for Regional Development of Ukraine, 2011. 71 p.
[13] DBN V.1.2-2:2006. System for ensuring the reliability and safety of construction objects. Loads and actions. Design standards. With changes No. 1 and No. 2. Valid from 2007-01-01. Kyiv: Ministry for Regional Construction, 2006. 70 p.
[14] DBN V.1.2-14:2018. The system for ensuring the reliability and safety of construction objects. General principles of ensuring the reliability and structural safety of buildings and structures. With change No. 1. Valid from 2022-09-01. Kyiv: Ministry of Regional Development, 2018. 36 p.
[15] Nelson H. Ukraine faces its most perilous winter yet. Atlantic Council, 31.10.2024. URL: https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/blogs/ukrainealert/ukraine-faces-its-most-perilous-winter-yet/ (Analytical review of the state of Ukraine’s energy system; includes data on 50% preserved equipment due to protection and quote about fortification resource demands) (application date 20.04.2025)
[16] Nashi Groshi. Unique photo of the consequences of a Shahed strike on a protective structure. NashiGroshi.org, 21.08.2024. URL: https://nashigroshi.org/2024/08/21/unikal-ne-foto-naslidkiv-udaru-shakheda-po-zakhysniy-sporudi-pidstantsii-ukrenerho-zroblenoi-z-budmaterialiv-po-rynkovykh-tsinakh/ (Article with photo showing the result of the screen — transformer survived; includes actual cost estimates of 120–150 million UAH) (application date 20.04.2025)
[17] Bannikov D. O., Nikiforova N. A., Kosiachevska S. M. Modern state of classification of transport building structures in ukraine. Bridges and Tunnels: Theory, Research, Practice. 2022. No. 21. P. 35-43.
[18] Hezentsvei Yu., Bannykov D. Effectiveness evaluation of steel strength improvement for pyramidal-prismatic bunkers. Eureka: Physics and Engineering. 2020. No. 2 (27). P. 30-38/
[19] Hezentsvei Y. I., Bannykov D. O. se of fine-grained heat-strengthened steels to increase the operational qualities of bunker capacities from thin-walled galvanized profiles. Science and Transport Progress. 2021. Is. 1 (91). P. 84-93.
[20] Bezsalyi V. M., Bannikov D. O. Efficiency of thin-walled galvanized profiles for arch elements. Bridges and Tunnels: Theory, Research, Practice. 2019. No. 16. P. 20-29.
+38 (067) 962-83-55
