NUMERICAL MODELING OF STRESS-STRAIN BEHAVIOR IN FRAME ROOFS OF VERTICAL STEEL TANKS
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.31650/2707-3068-2025-29-121-129Keywords:
Stress-strain state, vertical cylindrical tank, roof, finite element modelAbstract
The article presents the results of numerical modeling and stress-strain state analysis
of frame roofs of vertical cylindrical tanks with conical and spherical geometries. A comparative analysis of the efficiency of various structural solutions was carried out, considering both the presence and absence of the roof sheathing in finite element models.
Analytical calculation methods are complex, labor-intensive, and not always suitable for practical application. On the contrary, quite often, in convenient numerical calculation tools, models are simplified, which leads to unreliable results: underestimation or overestimation of stresses and deformations in load-bearing elements of coatings. In view of this, there is a need to study the impact of such simplifications on the accuracy of calculations and to justify their feasibility.
This study looked at roofing options without a central support. According to current design
standards, when calculating the covering of a vertical cylindrical tank, it's important to consider how the frame elements and sheet flooring work together. It was found that simplification of calculation schemes without modeling the sheathing leads to a significant overestimation of internal forces and deformations in the frame elements. Critical factors were identified for the main load-bearing components depending on the tank diameter, which allows substantiating the choice of roof type and rational structural solutions to improve the reliability and efficiency of steel tanks. The obtained results can be used to improve engineering calculation methods and optimize structural schemes of frame roofs in the design of large-diameter tanks.
References
1. Ефективні конструктивно-технологічні рішення об’єктів зберігання нафти і нафтопродуктів у складних інженерно-геологічних умовах: Монографія / В.О. Онищенко, Ю.Л. Винников, М.Л. Зоценко та ін. Полтава: ФОП Пусан А.Ф., 2019. 233 с.
2. Стороженко Л.І., Махінько А.В. Сталеві циліндричні резервуари: навч. посібник. Полтава: ПолтНТУ, 2012. 213 с.
3. Махінько А.В., Махінько Н.О. Сталеві ємносі для зберігання зерна. К.: Сталь, 2021.
4. Burgos C.A., Batista-Abreu J.C., Calabrо, H.D., Jaca R.C., Godoy L.A. 2015 Buckling estimates for oil storage tanks: Effect of simplified modeling of the roof and wind girder. Thin-Walled Structures. Vol. 91. P.29-37.
5. Lu S., Wang W. 2012 Dynamic response of fixed-roof oil-storage tank structure under blast loading. Journal of Southeast University (English Edition). Vol. 28, Issue 1, P. 58-63.
6. Sun X., Liu Y., Wang J., Cen Z. 2008 Stress and deflection analyses of floating roofs based on a load-modifying method. International Journal of Pressure Vessels. Vol. 85, Issue 10. P. 728-738.
7. Rasiulis K., Šapalas A., Vadluga R., Samofalov M. 2006 Stress/strain state investigations for extreme points of thin wall cylindrical tanks. Journal of Constructional Steel Research. Vol. 62, Issue 12, P. 1232-1237.
8. Zeybek Ö., Topkaya C., Rotter J.M. 2015 Strength and stiffness requirements for intermediate ring stiffeners on discretely supported cylindrical shells. Thin-Walled Structures. Vol. 96. P. 64-74.
9. Makhinko A., Makhinko N., Karpov V., Krayushkina K., Kordun O. 2024 New Sustainable and Economical Tank Shapes for the Oil and Gas Transport Infrastructure of Ukraine. Lecture Notes in Intelligent Transportation and Infrastructure. Vol. Part F2296. P. 379-385
10. Lopes M., Soeiro F., Silva J. G. 2024 Assessment of the dynamic structural behaviour of storage steel tanks. Journal of Constructional Steel Research. Vol. 221. 108936.
11. Tomoviс R., Dizdar S., Isiс S., Tuka S., Karabegoviс I. 2021. FEM analysis of inspection manhole on large steel tanks. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part E: Journal of Process Mechanical Engineering. Vol. 235, Issue 4, P. 1235-1247.
12. Chiang Y-C., Guzey S. 2019 Dynamic analysis of aboveground open-top steel tanks subjected to wind loading. Engineering StructuresVolume 198. 109496.
13. Kildashti K., Mirzadeh N., Samali B. 2017 Seismic vulnerability assessment of a case study anchored liquid storage tank by considering fixed and flexible base restraints. Thin-Walled Structures. Vol.123, P. 382-394.
14. Elansary A., El D.A. 2024 Seismic analysis of liquid storage composite conical tanks. Engineering Structures, Vol. 159. P 128- 140.
15. ДСТУ Б В.2.6-183:2011 Резервуари вертикальні циліндричні сталеві для нафти та нафтопродуктів. Загальні технічні умови. К.: Мінрегіон України, 2012. 87 с.




